What Is Identity Theft Versus Possession of Personal Data?

Identity theft and possession of personal data are distinct offenses, though they are often related and can lead to serious legal consequences. Identity theft involves the act of using someone else’s personal information without permission to commit fraud or gain unauthorized benefits. 

On the other hand, possession of personal data refers to simply having another person’s personal information without necessarily using it for fraudulent purposes. Both charges are treated as serious crimes under Arizona law, and penalties depend on the specific circumstances of the case. 

A Phoenix identity theft defense lawyer can help individuals accused of these crimes understand the charges they face and develop a legal strategy to address the situation.

What Is Identity Theft?

Identity theft occurs when someone intentionally uses another person’s personal identifying information to commit fraud. This crime can involve financial fraud, accessing services, or other unlawful activities, which is why hiring a Phoenix white collar crime defense lawyer sooner rather than later helps with a defense. 

Examples of Identity Theft

Some common examples of identity theft include:

• Using someone else’s name, Social Security number, or credit card information to make purchases
• Opening bank accounts or credit cards in another person’s name
• Filing fraudulent tax returns to obtain refunds
• Gaining access to medical services or benefits using another person’s insurance information
• Impersonating someone online to commit fraud or deceive others

Identity theft typically involves an intent to defraud, meaning the person accused knowingly used someone else’s personal information to gain something of value. A Phoenix criminal defense lawyer can determine which specific charges you face. 

What Is Possession of Personal Data?

Possession of personal data refers to having someone else’s private or identifying information in your possession without authorization. This could include Social Security numbers, credit card numbers, bank account information, or other types of sensitive data.

Examples of Possession of Personal Data

Some examples of this offense include:

• Holding onto stolen credit card information
• Possessing a database containing personal details, such as names and Social Security numbers, without a legitimate reason
• Having unauthorized access to stored personal information on a computer or device

Unlike identity theft, possession of personal data does not require the intent to commit fraud. However, the prosecution may argue that merely having the data suggests potential criminal intent, especially if the individual cannot provide a legitimate explanation for possessing it.

Key Differences Between Identity Theft and Possession of Personal Data

Although identity theft and possession of personal data are related, there are important distinctions between these offenses.

Intent to Commit Fraud

The main difference lies in intent. Identity theft requires proof that the individual used or intended to use someone else’s personal information for fraudulent purposes. Possession of personal data, on the other hand, does not require proof of intent to commit fraud. Simply having the data without authorization is enough to warrant charges.

Actions Taken

Identity theft involves actively using another person’s personal information, such as making purchases with a stolen credit card or opening accounts in someone else’s name. Possession of personal data involves no such action but focuses on the fact that the individual has unauthorized access to sensitive information.

Potential Charges

While both offenses are serious, identity theft is typically considered a more severe crime because it involves fraudulent actions. Possession of personal data may lead to separate charges, but the penalties are usually less severe unless the data is connected to a larger criminal activity.

Click to contact our criminal defense lawyers today

Penalties for Identity Theft

The penalties for identity theft in Arizona can be severe, depending on the circumstances of the case. Under Arizona law, identity theft is classified as a felony.

Felony Classifications and Penalties

• Class 4 felony: This is the most common classification for identity theft and can result in up to 3.75 years in prison for a first offense.
• Class 3 felony: If the offense involves aggravating factors, such as a larger scheme or organized criminal activity, it may be charged as a Class 3 felony, which carries a potential prison sentence of up to 8.75 years.

In addition to prison time, individuals convicted of identity theft may face:

• Restitution to victims
• Fines
• Permanent criminal records, which can affect employment and housing opportunities

Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now

Penalties for Possession of Personal Data

Possession of personal data is also a felony in Arizona, though the penalties depend on the specifics of the case.

Potential penalties can include:

• Class 6 felony: Simple possession of personal data without any evidence of fraud may be charged as a Class 6 felony, with a potential prison sentence of up to 2 years for a first offense.
• Higher felony classes: If the possession of personal data is connected to a larger criminal scheme or involves substantial amounts of data, the charge may be elevated to a higher felony class, resulting in more severe penalties.

As with identity theft, a conviction for possession of personal data can have long-term consequences, including difficulty finding employment and housing.

Potential Defenses to Identity Theft and Possession of Personal Data Charges

Defending against identity theft or possession of personal data charges requires a careful review of the evidence and circumstances. A lawyer can explore various defense strategies to protect the accused’s rights and challenge the prosecution’s case.

Lack of Intent

In identity theft cases, proving intent is necessary for the prosecution. If the defense can show that the accused did not intend to commit fraud, the charges may be reduced or dismissed.

Mistaken Identity

In some cases, the accused may be falsely identified as the perpetrator. This can happen if personal information was stolen or if the evidence is circumstantial. A defense lawyer can work to establish that the accused was not involved in the alleged crime.

Unlawful Search and Seizure

If law enforcement obtained evidence through an illegal search or seizure, the defense may argue that the evidence should be excluded from the case. Without key evidence, the prosecution’s case may weaken.

Legitimate Possession of Data

In possession of personal data cases, the accused may argue that they had a legitimate reason for having the information. For example, they may work in a role that requires handling sensitive data, or they may have been authorized to access the information.

Insufficient Evidence

The prosecution must prove every element of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. If the evidence is weak or incomplete, the defense can argue that the charges should be dismissed.

How Identity Theft and Possession of Personal Data Charges Are Investigated

Law enforcement agencies often use advanced tools and methods to investigate identity theft and possession of personal data cases. These investigations may involve:

• Reviewing financial records, credit reports, and transaction histories
• Analyzing electronic devices, such as computers and smartphones, for evidence of unauthorized data access
• Interviewing witnesses and victims of the alleged crime
• Collaborating with federal agencies, such as the FBI or Secret Service, in cases involving large-scale data breaches or fraud schemes

The investigative process can be lengthy and complex, and individuals under investigation may not even be aware that they are being scrutinized until charges are filed.

Contact Us for Help

If you are facing charges for identity theft or possession of personal data, we are here to help. At Suzuki Law Offices, we understand the serious consequences these charges can have on your life and future. Our team is ready to carefully evaluate your case and develop a defense strategy tailored to your situation.

Call us today for a free consultation. We are available 24/7 to discuss your case and provide the assistance you need. Let us help you protect your rights and work toward the best possible outcome.

Call or text (602) 682-5270 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form