A tragic 2017 homicide in Arizona has resurfaced in headlines after an unexpected online tip led to the arrest of a long-wanted suspect. The case underscores how digital footprints and public engagement can influence criminal investigations — even years later.
A Cold Case Rekindled
In June 2017, 25-year-old Evin Paulos was found dead in a desert area outside Phoenix. He had been stabbed roughly 30 times. For years, investigators struggled to locate a suspect, despite strong evidence pointing toward Michael Anthony Arredondo, a man who had once lived across the street from Paulos and later fled the country.
The investigation seemed to stall — until September 2025, when Paulos’s family received a message on their GoFundMe memorial page. The page had originally been created to raise funds and keep awareness alive, but one message stood out: a person in Mexico claimed to know where Arredondo was hiding.
Paulos’s sister asked for proof, and the tipster responded with a photo. That image reignited the case. Working with Mexican authorities, the Phoenix Police Department, and the U.S. Marshals Service, investigators tracked down Arredondo. He was arrested on October 15, 2025, and extradited to Arizona, where he now faces second-degree murder charges.
Committed to providing exceptional legal service to each and every client through integrity, compassion and experience.
Get StartedTechnology and Justice: A Modern Intersection
It’s not every day that a social-media or crowdfunding platform helps solve a homicide. Yet this case shows how online communication and public participation can play an important role in today’s criminal justice system.
Digital platforms — whether GoFundMe, Facebook, or even Reddit — can serve as modern tip lines. Families seeking closure often turn to these spaces for visibility and community support, but they can also become sources of new information. In this case, one message changed everything.
Legal and Investigative Lessons
For law enforcement, the arrest demonstrates persistence. Even after eight years, investigators continued to follow leads and coordinate internationally. As Detective Dominick Rostenberg noted at a press conference, the arrest sent a clear message:
“Even with the passage of time, we’re still looking for you — justice is going to take its course.”
For legal professionals, the case offers several takeaways:
-
Digital evidence matters. Communication through online platforms can become critical in criminal cases, whether for prosecution or defense.
-
Cross-border cooperation is key. Extraditions from countries like Mexico require coordination between multiple jurisdictions and agencies.
-
Emotional impact on families is profound. Victims’ relatives often carry years of unresolved grief and uncertainty. For them, closure — even partial — brings some measure of peace.
Click to contact our personal injury lawyers today
The Defense Perspective
While the arrest brings relief to the victim’s family, it also raises important questions for the defense side. When years pass before an arrest, witness memories fade, physical evidence degrades, and chain-of-custody issues can arise.
A defense attorney must carefully examine:
-
Whether confessions or statements were voluntary and legally obtained.
-
How long delays in investigation might affect fairness and due process.
-
Whether cross-border arrests complied with extradition and constitutional protections.
The right to a fair trial remains paramount — even in cases involving serious and emotional crimes.
Complete a Free Case Evaluation form now
Finding Justice in the Digital Age
The GoFundMe tip that led to this arrest is a striking example of how the pursuit of justice has evolved. Technology can both complicate and clarify investigations, offering new paths to accountability. For families, it’s a reminder that hope should never be lost. For defendants, it’s a call to ensure that due process is followed at every stage.
As this case moves forward in Arizona courts, it will likely continue to highlight both the power of persistence and the importance of legal safeguards — two principles that define our justice system.
Call or text (602) 682-5270 or complete a Free Case Evaluation form
